Former NFL QB buries Tom Brady in prime all-time QB rankings
· Yahoo Sports
Former NFL quarterback Chris Simms isn't convinced that Tom Brady was the greatest of all time—at least in his prime.
The NBC Sports NFL analyst made headlines by burying the seven-time Super Bowl-winning quarterback at No. 9 on his list. Brady's longtime rival, Peyton Manning, was ranked No. 1 on the list, with Patrick Mahomes coming in at No. 2 and Aaron Rodgers at No. 3.
Visit sportbet.rodeo for more information.
The other quarterbacks ranked ahead of Brady are John Elway, Brett Favre, Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson and Dan Marino. Simms fully expects to get major pushback for his rankings, but he tried to make sense of his placement for Brady.
"I know I'm probably going to get blowback for this right here, but Tom Brady did get afforded the luxury, especially in his prime and early years of, 'We're not asking you to carry the team. Belichick is going to come up with an unbelievable game plan. We're gonna run the ball, be physical, and then we just need you to be clutch at the end of the football game,'" Simms said. "He certainly had a few years that were awesome in his prime. I'm certainly not trying to downplay that. ...If you put him in some other situations, I don't know if it would have looked as pretty that way."
The Sheriff clocks in at No. 1. ☝️ pic.twitter.com/63boUh62Sq
— Sunday Night Football on NBC (@SNFonNBC) July 13, 2026
As Simms predicted, his Brady take did not go over well with NFL fans.
X was full of fans posting their disagreements with Brady's ranking on the list. Here were some of the best reactions from the social media site:
Bro Brady threw for 5000 yards and 50 TD's and went 16-0 in his prime and 14 years later he threw for 5300 yards and 43 TD's. His prime lasted a decade and a half and was better than anyone's peak.
— Cerrone Battle (@Cerrone_Battle) July 13, 2026
Brady vs. Manning in the playoffs. Essentially equal performance in Wild Card round games. In later rounds, Manning turned into a pumpkin while Brady was mostly great
— Andrew (@617_andrew) July 13, 2026
Statistically, Manning gets the edge in the regular season. But let’s not pretend Brady wasn’t throwing to Deion… pic.twitter.com/oyROU2P4xL
Simms is beyond jealous of Brady. Comical
— Wasting My Hate (@redmeatnwhisky) July 13, 2026
Dumb list. Brady was waxing half the guys on this list during their "primes"
— tontoon🇺🇸 (@tontoon81) July 13, 2026
Brett Favre ahead of Brady? Lmao. Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson ahead of Brady?
— TheDadAbidesYo (@TheDadAbidesYo) July 14, 2026
Is this satire?
Somehow Tom Brady is still underrated. pic.twitter.com/jaAuHRvUKe
— Andrew (@AndrewQ24_7) July 13, 2026
What did Tom Brady do to make Chris Simms hate him 😂
— Stats (@NFLSTATISTIC) July 13, 2026
this is the worst list i have ever seen. Love peyton… i’ll equate it to basketball. Finals mvps mean EVERYTHING. It’s literally the only reason. why you play. Brady has so may more big moments and so many more. clutch performances
— Samuel L Smith (@SamuelLSmith6) July 14, 2026
Chris Simms = Biggest Brady hater of all time. It’s pathetic at this point
— Jeremy Morris (@jeremym555) July 14, 2026
Not even trying to hide it pic.twitter.com/oimfMp2qSB
— Slimm 🦅 (@Dizzy_3D) July 13, 2026
Follow Patriots Wire on Twitter and Facebook.
This article originally appeared on Patriots Wire: Former NFL QB buries Tom Brady in prime all-time QB rankings