Nashville SC out to complete MLS Cup-Supporters' Shield history

· Yahoo Sports

Nashville SC out to complete MLS Cup-Supporters' Shield history

By Ben Wright

NASHVILLE – In Major League Soccer's 31-year history, only eight Supporters’ Shield winners have gone on to win MLS Cup presented by Audi.

Visit afsport.lat for more information.

Nashville SC are looking to become the ninth, starting with Sunday's Round One Best-of-3 Series opener vs. FC Cincinnati (4 pm ET | Apple TV; FS1, FOX Deportes).

The Boys in Gold made history during the regular season, setting league records for points (77), wins (23), home wins (15), goals conceded (25), and fewest losses (3). Add a Concacaf Champions Cup semifinal run in the spring, and they’ve compiled one of the best seasons in recent memory.

However, Nashville know that it will all ultimately feel like a disappointment if they don’t complete an MLS Cup-Supporters' Shield double by lifting the Philip F. Anschutz Trophy on Dec. 18.

"We were happy to break the record. That was the goal in the end. We achieved it, and now it's almost a new season. A new tournament starts,” club captain Hany Mukhtar said on Tuesday.

“We need to be very sharp and locked in to know what is on the line, but also to know that we are the best team ever, and we should have the confidence.”

⚽🏆 ALL FOR THE CUP

Every match matters. Don't miss a moment of the Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs.

Watch on Apple TV

Team of destiny?

It’s hard not to look at Nashville and expect them to win it all. By virtue of winning the Shield, they’ll play all but one of their Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs matches at GEODIS Park, including MLS Cup, should they reach it. They’ve been virtually automatic at their home stadium this year, going 15W-0L-2D and outscoring their opponents 48-14.

They’re leaning on their experiences winning the US Open Cup in 2025 and making a run to the 2026 Concacaf Champions Cup semifinals, in which they became the first MLS team to ever win at Mexico City’s Estadio Azteca, as tangible proof that they can deliver with everything on the line.

“There is a different mindset, but we have shown, last year in Open Cup and this year in the Champions League, that we are capable of knockout situations and having the pressure a little bit on,” said Mukhtar, the 2022 Landon Donovan MLS MVP.

“At the end of the day, there's nothing to fear. We have beaten all of them. We just need to do what we do best.”

At the same time, Nashville know they have a target on their backs and history against them. While Shield winners rarely lift MLS Cup, there's some modern-day MLS precedent after LAFC completed the double in 2022.

“We look at this as an extension of the regular season; we want to continue to do the same preparation, the same process of how we're gonna prepare for an opponent,” said head coach B.J. Callaghan.

“I think this team is a team that maybe history hasn't had to always define it. Our guys are focused on understanding that the guarantee that we have is a three-game series. The whole regular season has earned ourselves just a three-game series.”

Elite defense

Nashville’s attack has made headlines all season, and rightfully so. Their Designated Player trio of Mukhtar, Sam Surridge and Cristian Espinoza has formed one of the most lethal frontlines in MLS, propelling them to 71 goals, the third-most in 2026.

Going into the playoffs, though, they’re even more confident because of a historically elite defense. Nashville tied the MLS record with 17 clean sheets and allowed just 25 goals, the fewest in the modern era of MLS. Even on an off night for their attack – a rarity – their refusal to allow goals keeps the floor high.

“Here we are keeping clean sheets and conceding less,” said center back Maxwell Woledzi, recently named MLS Defender of the Year. “For me it's a huge achievement knowing that we are doing well at the back.”

Under Callaghan, Nashville have made a concerted effort to be miserable to play against. Their mantra of “everybody attacks, everybody defends” may sound cliché or like coach speak, but it’s consistently banked results. Mukhtar and the rest of the attackers view themselves as the first defenders, responsible for pressuring opponents and forcing turnovers. This has made Nashville a stifling team to play against, winning the ball back almost as soon as they lose it and rarely allowing their opponents space to breathe.

“We know that if you want to be a team who wins games, you can attack and you can be a good attacking team,” said Mukhtar. “But if you want to win championships and titles, you need to be difficult to play against, and everyone needs to defend. That's the DNA of the club.”

Ready for more

By the time Nashville face Cincy on Sunday, they’ll have gone just over two weeks between competitive games. Callaghan isn’t worried about a loss of form, but instead says the game can’t come quickly enough.

“We've all spent a lot of time here in the last seven or 10 days together, and we're excited to just get out there and compete,” he said. “It's an added bonus that we get to do it at home, in a place that I think we've had really good form, and that's due to the level of support that we get from the crowd. We'll be able to use that to our advantage.”

Nashville were a good team in 2025, lifting the US Open Cup and taking eventual champions Inter Miami CF to three matches in their Round One series. They’re significantly better in 2026.

“We are more diverse now. We are very good in a lot of phases of the game,” said Mukhtar. “When you look at other teams who have won the league, most of the time you pick one or two things about them and say, ‘okay, they're very good in transition,' or ‘they're good at pressing.’

"But I think in general, where we made the biggest strides is in all phases… There are so many phases where we have improved, and the biggest thing for me is the mentality.”

Surridge put it even more succinctly.

“I think we were a really good team last year," the English No. 9 stated. "But this season, I think we're a great team.”

Read full story at source