Silicon Valley Is Scrambling Now

· The Atlantic

This is an edition of The Atlantic Daily, a newsletter that guides you through the biggest stories of the day, helps you discover new ideas, and recommends the best in culture. Sign up for it here.

Visit palladian.co.za for more information.

In The Lord of the Rings, a palantir is a crystal ball that allows users to peer into the future—but it gives only partial information. This might have been a warning to Alex Karp, the CEO of the tech company named Palantir. Earlier this year, Karp crowed that AI would reduce the power of “highly educated, often female voters, who vote mostly Democrat.”

Postelection, he’s singing a different tune. “I’ve been a Democrat my whole life. I grew up in a far-left environment,” Karp recently told Politico. “I know more about being a progressive than almost anybody on the planet, and I absolutely believe Palantir—all of our products are essentially progressive.” He used that last word, progressive, eight times in the interview. Karp also claimed that he’d been critical of Donald Trump in private, though he somehow decided to disclose it only now.

His fellow tech titan Elon Musk—once described as Trump’s “co-president” and the biggest donor to his 2024 campaign—now says he’s “not MAGA” and “doesn’t know what MAGA means.” Perhaps he should have inquired before he made MAGA hats part of his wardrobe. Musk’s SpaceX is backing off from referring to the “Gulf of America” too.

These flips are particularly brazen (and unconvincing), but they are not unique. On Election Night, as the size of Democrats’ victory became clear, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman, who had praised the Trump administration for producing a “breath of fresh air” in Silicon Valley, declared, “People should always be in control of the future.” Kalshi abruptly cut ties with Donald Trump Jr. Meanwhile, Dana White, the Ultimate Fighting Championship impresario who’d spoken at the Republican National Convention and whom Trump had recently suggested as White House press secretary, said that he wants “nothing to do with politics.” If he grasped the irony of saying this on Lara Trump’s Fox News show, he didn’t let it on.

Jeff Bezos is also tempering his enthusiasm for Trump, saying that he is “on the side of America,” not either party, and noting that he has worked with “every president since Clinton.” VIPs who rushed to get tickets to a Trump crypto gala in years past are no longer so eager. The podcaster Joe Rogan, a major influence on young men who swung to Trump in the 2024 election, is now disillusioned. “They didn’t just lose the podcast bros,” he said. “They lost most of the country.”

Emily Litella—the Saturday Night Live character with the catchphrase “Never mind”—would feel right at home with this bunch. The clumsy reversals have inevitably been labeled, in the au courant fashion, a “vibe shift.” This is perhaps an apt description. Postelection, it is tempting to treat these statements from corporate leaders as evidence of a major paradigm change. In reality, they are better understood as ephemeral marketing.

For many years, big companies tried to avoid getting sucked into divisive political issues. (The billionaire Michael Jordan crisply encapsulated the reason when he said, “Republicans buy sneakers too.”) But the killing of George Floyd in 2020, and the enormous demonstrations that followed, led some business leaders to adopt public social-justice stances. Others announced after the January 6 riot that they would no longer donate to election deniers. This drew the ire of Republicans who labeled it “woke capital,” a possible contradiction in terms. As I wrote at the time, though, “These corporations are acting in a majoritarian manner. But no one should conclude that they are progressive.”

Indeed, when Trump returned to office, the corporate establishment quickly adapted itself to the new regime, moving to accommodate Trump by giving large donations or by shutting down DEI programs. (Some of the companies that had pledged to halt giving to deniers quietly dropped their commitment.) Institutions that forcefully jumped on the Trump bandwagon were responding to analysis that suggested that the 2024 election represented a serious and lasting change in American politics. As it turned out, the shift was just vibes—fleeting and easily dispelled rather than solid and real. By late this summer, the problems of betting on Trump were becoming apparent, and the scale of Democrats’ victories in the midterms now has executives rushing to get back in their good graces.

One element of these reversals is that people have shortsighted perspectives on politics, tending to overrate the importance of whatever the most recent election result was. In this century alone, pundits and operatives have declared both major political parties dead, yet they both remain peskily alive. No one should be surprised if executives are just as prone to overestimating the durability of any new ruling coalition.

The more important factor, though, is prudent (or, depending on whom you ask, cynical) business concerns: Companies like Palantir and SpaceX rely heavily on government contracts; Kalshi and OpenAI need a friendly regulatory environment. Should a Republican win the 2028 election, expect progressive to vanish from Alex Karp’s vernacular just as quickly as it entered. Big companies will always seek to curry favor, and elected officials are too often susceptible to their flattery, no matter how shallow. These transactional relationships serve both sides well, but they don’t necessarily serve the people.

Related:

Here are three new stories from The Atlantic:

Today’s News

  1. Donald Trump tapped Kirsten A. Davies to be the new national cyber director yesterday after a series of countrywide outages sparked concern over America’s technological infrastructure.
  2. A second federal judge has blocked the construction of Trump’s triumphal arch, describing the project as a “rush job” that lacks legal basis.
  3. The Justice Department abandoned its lawsuit from last month against Alaska; the lawsuit sought to prevent the Democrat Mary Peltola from winning a Senate seat. Peltola won her race three days ago against the Republican incumbent, Dan S. Sullivan.

Dispatches

Explore all of our newsletters here.

Evening Read

Rockstar Games

Grand Theft Auto VI Is Really Weird

By Ian Bogost

Jason Duval lives in a shack on the Leonida Keys, in the simulated Florida where Grand Theft Auto VI is set. I began playing the game after its release at midnight, and I have already tried and failed to outrun the police, roamed the hallways of a prison, driven a speedboat to collect cocaine dropped by a seaplane pilot who was skimming from a more upmarket criminal, and flown the seaplane to escape an RV park full of wild-animal-and-narcotics traffickers.

If you know anything at all about the game, which almost 5,000 people worked on for more than a decade at a reported cost of more than $1 billion, it is that Leonida is enormous. Early reviewers are bragging on social media about spending more than 100 hours in the world of the game, while only scratching the surface of what is possible. The prospect seems overwhelming because I already have a life that requires labor and demands diversion, and I am worried about how to fit GTA VI’s simulated work and recreation into my supposedly real life.

Read the full article.

More From The Atlantic

Culture Break

Lionsgate

Watch (or skip). The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping (out now in theaters) struggles to find meaning in its violent spectacle.

Explore. Art museums have to get creative right now. But the Taylor Swift exhibition is an SOS call—museums can do better than this, Kelsey Ables argues.

Play our daily crossword.

Stephanie Bai contributed to this newsletter.

When you buy a book using a link in this newsletter, we receive a commission. Thank you for supporting The Atlantic.

Read full story at source